Category Archives: Uncategorized

HMP Portland: 62% of HMIP Previous Recommendations Not Implemented At This Violent & Unsafe Prison


Screen Shot 2017-09-20 at 15.54.53SAFETY: Reception staff were very welcoming, and procedures for new arrivals were appropriate. The first night unit was a decent environment where prisoners felt supported. Too many prisoners felt unsafe and levels of violence were very high. Self-harm was also high and often serious. The establishment’s response to diminished safety was inadequate. The incentives and earned privileges (IEP) scheme was used inconsistently, and the adjudication system failed to deal with many serious charges. Despite the widespread availability of drugs, the prison lacked a meaningful supply reduction action plan. Use of force was high and its governance was unacceptably weak. The segregation environment and regime were poor. Substance misuse support had improved since the last inspection and was good. Outcomes for prisoners were poor against this healthy prison test. At the last inspection in July 2014 we found that outcomes for prisoners in Portland were reasonably good against this healthy prison test. We made 21 recommendations in the area of safety. At this follow-up inspection we found that six of the recommendations had been achieved, three had been partially achieved and 12 had not been achieved.

RESPECT: Living conditions for most prisoners were poor. Cramped cells lacked privacy and contained graffiti and offensive displays. Prisoner access to basic amenities and facilities was often restricted. We witnessed many positive interactions between staff and prisoners. Despite this, too many managers and staff had failed to notice and address poor conditions, behaviour and treatment. Prisoners lacked confidence in the application and complaints systems. Equality and diversity work was not given sufficient priority, and there was limited consultation with minority groups of prisoners. A wellintegrated chaplaincy provided good support. Significant health staff shortages limited mental health support, but primary health services were reasonably good overall. The quality and quantity of food provided were not always sufficient. Outcomes for prisoners were not sufficiently good against this healthy prison test. At the last inspection in July 2014 we found that outcomes for prisoners in Portland were not sufficiently good against this healthy prison test. We made 28 recommendations in the area of respect. At this follow-up inspection we found that eight of the recommendations had been achieved, four had been partially achieved and 16 had not been achieved.

PURPOSEFUL ACTIVITY: Time out of cell was insufficient for a category C prison and was made worse by the frequent regime slippage and cumbersome unlock procedures. Good partnership working between the prison and the college provider had led to an increase in vocational and work places and there were now sufficient activity spaces for most prisoners, but the regime frequently hindered access, punctuality and attendance. The quality of provision was mostly good, and prisoners behaved well in activities when they got there. Achievements in training and education were good. Library facilities were good but access was poor. The PE department offered vocational qualifications, but some prisoners had limited access to recreational gym. Outcomes for prisoners were not sufficiently good against this healthy prison test. At the last inspection in July 2014 we found that outcomes for prisoners in Portland were poor against this healthy prison test. We made 18 recommendations in the area of purposeful activity. At this follow-up inspection we found that 12 of the recommendations had been achieved, one partially achieved, four not achieved and one no longer relevant.

RESETTLEMENT: The strategic management of resettlement had improved and appropriate structures were in place. However, there was a lack of effective management in the offender management unit (OMU). The significant backlog of OASys (offender assessment system) assessments affected many aspects of resettlement work. Offender supervisor contact and support for prisoners was hindered by frequent cross-deployment. There was an unacceptable backlog of home detention curfew (HDC) applications. Significant weaknesses in the management of public protection meant that we could not be sure if risk was managed safely. The community rehabilitation company (CRC)2 provided a good resettlement service, although there was not enough joint working with the OMU. Resettlement pathways work was variable. Outcomes for prisoners were not sufficiently good against this healthy prison test. At the last inspection in July 2014 we found that outcomes for prisoners in Portland were not sufficiently good against this healthy prison test. We made 14 recommendations in the area of resettlement. At this follow-up inspection we found that four of the recommendations had been achieved, one had been partially achieved and nine had not been achieved.


HMP/YOI Portland is a category C prison located on Portland Bill, Dorset. It is an historic prison, originally built in 1848, housing around 500 adult and young adult male prisoners. The prison was last inspected in 2014, when it was judged to be fundamentally safe, but on this occasion there had been a marked decline in safety, which was now judged to be poor.

This was a serious and disappointing judgement that was rooted in a number of findings.

In our survey, half of prisoners said they had felt unsafe at some time, and one in four felt unsafe at the time of the inspection. The latter figure is double what it was in 2014. Levels of violence were very high, as was the level of self-harm – individual incidents of which were often serious. There did not appear to be a coordinated strategy to deal with the violence, and indeed there were significant failings in the response to it. In light of these levels of violence, it was not surprising that the use of force was higher than at comparable establishments.

However, the governance of the use of force was unacceptably poor.

Much paperwork connected with it was incomplete and not all planned interventions were filmed. Inexplicably, although body-worn cameras were available, they were not routinely used nor was their footage reviewed. Just as the issue of violence required urgent management intervention, so too did there need to be a coherent strategy to reduce the supply of illicit drugs into the prison. 64% of prisoners surveyed told us it was easy to get drugs. Only one prison had returned a higher figure than that in the past year. Meanwhile, 20% said they had actually developed a drug problem since being in the prison. It was clear that the ready availability of drugs was contributing to the levels of debt, bullying and violence that were evident throughout the prison.

Another symptom of the problem was the number of prisoners self-isolating across the jail. In terms of the conditions in which prisoners were held, too many of the cells in the residential wings were in poor condition. Many of the double cells had unscreened lavatories that were extremely close to the beds in which men slept and ate their meals. Equally concerning was that some prisoners and staff had come to accept such conditions as normal. To my surprise, a senior member of staff showed me a double cell where a sheet had been used to screen the shower, with another fashioned into a makeshift curtain over the window, and told me in all seriousness that this was an example of a ‘good’ cell. The segregation unit was in poor condition, with cells damaged by previous occupants, sinks and lavatories ripped away and repairs taking too long to achieve.

However, despite the violence, drugs and poor living conditions, the relationships between staff and prisoners seemed generally good. We observed many positive interactions, and the workshops in particular were a good example of cooperative and collaborative relationships. Prisoners said that they felt as if they had left the confines of the prison while they were at activities. This was encouraging, but in other respects the balance had tipped too far towards acceptance of low-level poor behaviour. At the time of the inspection the smoking ban had been in place for a few weeks, but it was clear that it was being widely ignored, and that this was being tolerated by staff. More seriously, inspectors were also left with the very clear impression, and I was explicitly told by more than one prisoner, that staff were not intervening sufficiently to stop some of the violence and bullying on the wings.

For a category C prison, the prisoners were locked up for too much of the time. More than 30% of them were locked in their cells during the working day, restricting their access to many elements of the regime. There needed to be a thorough review with the intention of finding out what was achievable as opposed to what was convenient for the establishment.

There were many good things happening at Portland, but we were left with the clear view that there was a need for effective leadership to take Portland into the future and to shake off many of the vestiges of the past. A new governor was appointed a few weeks before the inspection, and he has the opportunity to ensure that each and every member of his management team is accountable for leading key areas of activity, and that standards are maintained in the services that give rise to frustration from prisoners when they are not efficiently or consistently delivered.

Our survey gave clear indications of what these things were. Too much was delegated outside the governing team. The governor and his senior team now have an opportunity to seize the initiative and drive forward the improvements that are badly needed at Portland.

IMB Reform: National Council to be Scrapped and Replaced by a Chair and Management Board

The Secretary of State for Justice, Liz Truss, has approved plans to overhaul the national governance structure for Independent Monitoring Boards (IMBs). In July 2014 the Ministry of Justice received an independent report it had commissioned by Karen Page Associates (KPA) (read the report) which looked at the current national IMB system of monitoring in… Continue Reading

Prison Governors may be given greater flexibility in education focus

Prison governors could be given greater flexibility under plans being considered by Michael Gove to relax the grip of Whitehall on the penal system. The Justice Secretary wants a greater focus on education in prisons and more businesses working with inmates to help reduce the risk of reoffending when offenders are released. Mr Gove said… Continue Reading

Four plead to Hatton Garden raid

Four men have admitted their role in plotting the Hatton Garden Easter raid which saw valuables worth more than £10 million stolen. They are John Collins, 74, of Blestoe Walk, Islington, north London; Daniel Jones, 58, of Park Avenue, Enfield, north London; Terry Perkins, 67, of Heene Road, Enfield, north London; and Brian Reader, 76, of… Continue Reading

Answer on Terrorist Prisoners Demanded

Ministers must urgently reveal how many prisoners convicted of terror offences have been released from jail on licence so Britain can assess the risk it faces in the wake of the Paris attacks, the Commons has heard. Tory MP Philip Davies (Shipley) said it was “absolutely essential” for the Government to divulge the information in… Continue Reading

Nearly 50 Gangs in Feltham YOI

Inmates at a jail for teenagers represent 48 different gangs, inspectors have discovered, fuelling a “constant juggling” by prison officers to keep the boys apart. There were high levels of “unpredictable and reckless” violence among the 240 boys aged 15 to 18 at Feltham Young Offenders’ Institution (YOI), a significant amount of which was gang-related,… Continue Reading

Call on custody transport vehicles

Men, women and children should not be transported between courts and prisons in the same vehicles, the Chief Inspector of Prisons has said. Her Majesty’s Inspectorate of Prisons (HMIP) found escort vans run by private contractors GeoAmey, Serco Wincanton and Secure Escort Services for Children and Young People (SESCYP), carried a mixture of men, women… Continue Reading

Cop charged with assault

A police officer accused of being drunk and disorderly has also been charged with attempting to resist arrest and obstructing police, Scotland Yard said. Mark Toulson, 33, a serving Metropolitan Police officer from Wandsworth, will appear at Wimbledon Magistrates’ Court on December 12. He is charged with being drunk and disorderly, using threatening behaviour, two… Continue Reading